From eb2002fde84150be9c68e5f98680cf9d5252ec5e Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Raymond Hill Date: Tue, 22 Jul 2014 17:11:14 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?Updated=20=C2=B5Block=20and=20others:=20Blockin?= =?UTF-8?q?g=20ads,=20trackers,=20malwares=20(markdown)?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit --- ...others:-Blocking-ads,-trackers,-malwares.md | 72 ++++++++++--------- 1 file changed, 38 insertions(+), 34 deletions(-) diff --git a/µBlock-and-others:-Blocking-ads,-trackers,-malwares.md b/µBlock-and-others:-Blocking-ads,-trackers,-malwares.md index ad97ae9..f265188 100644 --- a/µBlock-and-others:-Blocking-ads,-trackers,-malwares.md +++ b/µBlock-and-others:-Blocking-ads,-trackers,-malwares.md @@ -17,53 +17,54 @@ domains reported as "3rd-party" actually belong to the same entity which owns th Results -- figures are "**3rd party** / all". Ordered from least 3rd-party hits to most 3rd-party hits. Privacy-wise, lower numbers are better. -#### µBlock 0.2.1.1 +#### µBlock 0.2.3.3 -- Domains: **240** / 300 -- Hosts: 396 / 609 -- Scripts: 584 / 866 -- Outbound cookies: 1 / 105 -- Net requests: 2,452 / 5,007 +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **246** +- Scripts: 569 / 852 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 112 +- Net requests: 2,458 / 5,020 #### Adblock Plus 1.8.3 -- Domains: **251** / 311 -- Hosts: 408 / 621 -- Scripts: 609 / 890 -- Outbound cookies: 1 / 111 -- Net requests: 2,503 / 5,079 - -#### Adguard 1.0.2.12 - -- Domains: **274** / 334 -- Hosts: 454 / 681 -- Scripts: 645 / 934 +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **255** +- Scripts: 563 / 839 - Outbound cookies: 1 / 120 -- Net requests: 2,573 / 5,189 +- Net requests: 2,415 / 4,963 #### Ghostery 5.3.0 -- Domains: **280** / 340 -- Hosts: 463 / 712 -- Scripts: 598 / 899 -- Outbound cookies: 1 / 120 -- Net requests: 2,560 / 5,260 +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **283** +- Scripts: 589 / 894 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 135 +- Net requests: 2,605 / 5,301 + +#### Adguard 1.0.2.12 + +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **283** +- Scripts: 637 / 930 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 136 +- Net requests: 2,600 / 5,251 #### Disconnect 5.18.14 -- Domains: **361** / 421 -- Hosts: 617 / 862 -- Scripts: 751 / 1029 -- Outbound cookies: 1 / 169 -- Net requests: 2,740 / 5,314 +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **352** +- Scripts: 716 / 989 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 174 +- Net requests: 2,704 / 5,276 + +#### Privacy Badger 2014-07-18 + +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **604** +- Scripts: 853 / 1181 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 182 +- Net requests: 3,190 / 5,990 #### No blocker -- Domains: **1191** / 1251 -- Hosts: 1820 / 2105 -- Scripts: 1506 / 1854 -- Outbound cookies: 1 / 210 -- Net requests: 5,439 / 8,388 +- Distinct 1st-party-3rd-party connections: **1160** +- Scripts: 1471 / 1799 +- Outbound cookies: 1 / 216 +- Net requests: 5,317 / 8,207 ### Notes @@ -73,7 +74,9 @@ the reference benchmark (average of three repeats in the current instance). The less hits on 3rd-party servers, the better. -Note that Adguard sends `GET` requests in the form `https://sb.adtidy.org/safebrowsing-lookup-domain.html?domain={page hostname}` for the first time a URL is visited. This may be related to its _"Phishing and malware protection"_ setting. Just a guess. +Adguard: it sends `GET` requests in the form `https://sb.adtidy.org/safebrowsing-lookup-domain.html?domain={page hostname}` for the first time a URL is visited. This may be related to its _"Phishing and malware protection"_ setting. Just a guess. + +Privacy Badger: warning from the browser: _"This extension is slowing down Chromium. You should disable it to restore Chromium's performance."_ ### Methodology @@ -84,6 +87,7 @@ All blockers were configured in such a way as to compare apples-vs-apples: - **Ghostery:** out-of-the-box settings + _"Advertising"_, _"Analytics"_, _"Beacons"_, _"Privacy"_ checked. _"Widgets"_ not checked. _"GhostRank"_ not checked. _"Update now"_ clicked (and ensured whatever new filters were used). - **Adguard:** out-of-the-box settings + _"Spyware and tracking"_, _"Phishing and malware protection"_ checked. _"Social media"_ not checked. _"Acceptable ads"_ unchecked. _"Check for filter updates"_ clicked. - **Disconnect:** out-of-the-box settings -- no change. +- **Privacy Badger:** out-of-the-box settings -- no change. Browser settings (if you mind your privacy, there is no way around these settings): - _"Click to play"_ enabled.